Exploring the Unique Timbre of the Violin in  Ottoman Music

 

This artistic research investigates the timbre of the violin in Ottoman music from the perspective of a musician outside the tradition. Its goal is not only to understand how this distinctive sound is created but also to experience how cultural, historical, and stylistic influences shape it.

Approaching the tradition as both learner and artist, I learn from master musicians, immerse myself in traditional musical environments, and engage in reflective creative practice. I explore how violinists trained in Western classical music can enter this tradition respectfully, embody its nuances, and remain true to its core.

Using four guiding frameworks—tacit knowledge, meşk (oral transmission), cultural immersion, and instrument modification—I document a journey of listening, learning, and transformation. This process integrates literature review, conceptual framing, artistic methodology, and reflective analysis, turning the violin into a space where diverse musical traditions engage in meaningful dialogue.

Key outcomes of this study show that timbre in Ottoman violin playing is not fixed but culturally constructed and personally shaped. Timbre is deeply contextual, influenced by cultural models like the human voice and traditional instruments, and expressed through subtle choices in vibrato, ornamentation, bowing, and instrument setup. The expressive identity of Ottoman music relies on sensitivity and subtlety, with small variations significantly affecting the emotional and modal character of the music.

Learning in this tradition depends heavily on embodied, tacit knowledge passed down orally through the meşk system, where core concepts such as makam nuance and microtonality are absorbed through long-term listening, singing, and playing alongside masters. Deep listening and cultural immersion were essential for developing stylistic understanding, revealing nuances that notation alone cannot capture.

 

Click on the pdf below to download the thesis. In several sections of the thesis, you will be led to this exposition which contains the supporting Audio and visual material. 

15. Echoes of Elsewhere, composition played at Bachelor Concert (Black Box, Musiikkitalo, May 2025)

7. Hijaz Saz Semai-Derya Turkan Labyrinth workshops, Gent, April 2024

11. Hafız Kemal – (Gazel-vocal improvisation) Hasretle Bu Şeb

1. Nubar Tekyay- Şevk-Efzâ Taksim (violin)

4. Haydar Tatlıyay - Uşşak Taksim (Violin)

12. Kânî Karaca - Hicaz şarkı - Şevkî Bey

8. Ahmet Erdogdular-Şevk-U Tarâb Taksim (kemençe)

2. Nubar Tekyay - Sabâ Taksim (violin)

5. Learning the Teslim of Hicaz Peşrev (Refik Fersan) – Lesson with Derya Türkan

13. Kani Karaca – singing the seyir of Bayati makam

9. Tanburi Cemil Bey - Hicaz Taksim (Yaylı Tanbur)

3. Nubar Tekyay and Ercümend Batanay - Kürdilihicazkâr Peşrev & Saz Semaisi

6. Learning Uşşak Oyun Havası (Haydar Tatlıyay) – Lesson with Burak Savaş

14. Burak Savaş (voice) -Kürdilihicazkâr Şarkı – Gel Gitme Kadın (Selahattin Pınar)

10. Sadettin Kaynak – Gazel: “Aşka düştüm cân-ı dil müşfik civânan oldu hep” (Rast)