Working on a series of experimental paintings from outdoors observation and then in the studio, I ended up with the basic questions about what happens at the borders of two colours and how we formalise external sensory information. Working directly with paint, without preparatory sketches or underlying drawings before applying paint, was a revealing challenge of painting’s possibilities as a stand alone practice, but also as discourse. I first experimented with the painterly technique of pouring liquid paint directly onto paper and moving the paper around to apply the paint for painting a tree branch from life. Although this process was difficult to control for a realistic result - which led me initially to call the series “Something I cannot control” - it was appropriate for expressing the movement of the tree branch with the wind and the changes in light caused by that movement.

Colour and movement

Back in the studio, I singled out a small part of one of the paintings to make a larger painting with brushes, without any underlying drawing again, by paying attention to the areas that were not covered with paint when I was trying the pouring technique. In that stage, the initial object of observation was not relevant anymore. Instead, the emerging inquiry was about the edges of methodically painted surfaces. I noticed there was an almost imperceptible area at the borders of different areas of colour that were neither one colour, nor the other. I wanted to purposefully expose these areas by meticulously smudging the edges of the painted surfaces to make visible that there is a small area around the edges, which remains undecided.

I

art theory



I made the last series of paintings by setting the time of 1’ for each painting, to test the limits of the medium and to see what kind of result I would get when I set specific restrictions. To achieve this, I asked other painters if they would let me borrow the colours they had already mixed; in exchange, I would make a painting that says something about them, since I would be using their own colours. The theme of the natural landscape remained for the economy of the task. I exploited the primer’s whiteness for giving a sense of light and texture to the paintings, although I made them in the studio.

scroll

right

II

normativity



Oil on primed paper, A2

donated, 2019

                                                                                                                         

enlightenment panel

number 1


2010 - 11

2016-17         

 

 

Cezanne pioneered a modern approach in painting that aimed at searching for the truth beyond physical stimuli and sensations, some kind of structure of the physical things. He wanted to see the physical world that he was observing as an object, without the mind’s input that orders adopting a perspectival system, nor the subjective feelings, like his predecessors, the impressionists (Read, 1974: 19). Cezanne’s research served this purpose: for art to achieve a structural order out of the visual impressions. This theoretical approach to art, signaling a heroic effort to overcome romanticism (Read, 1974: 28), intended to formalise an artistic order that corresponds with nature’s order (Read, 1974: 27).

III

skepticism

Cezanne’s view of creating an almost geometric order out of visual stimuli later became the inspiration for the cubists. However, by then it had become accepted that the creativity of the plastic arts can lead not necessarily to the stability of a perspectival view that serves the need to order the optical impressions with the objective coherence of an already constructed geometric system, but also to the free combination of whichever visual element, whether from nature or construed a priori (Read, 1974: 108). From that moment on, the artist is liberated from the tradition of the plastic arts of the past to create new artistic systems.


creating borders with sound and light

2019

However, as Read (1974: 108) explains, there is an obvious distinction between the artist who attempts to address the viewer’s sensibilities working from perception to representation, or from perception to imagination, deconstructing visual images and recomposing them to a non-representational, rational or conceptual, new order.


1   year  artwork

ground floor flat

2016     -     2017

DIY    guidelines

WORK IN PROGRESS

 

Paul Cezanne - The Garden at Les Lauves, 1906

scroll up

For Delaunay, order was found in and somehow was imposed by colour itself:

“[…] Real French art, completely clear and absolute representation, constructed according to the laws of light, or rather of colour, that is to say, purely visual, with a new craft, as was great Italian painting with its old craft; in reaction against all the cerebral incoherences of the cubists, the futurists, centrists, rayonists, integrists, cerebrists, abstractionists, expressionists, dynamists, patheticism (to the exclusion of some distinctions in the research of colour: fauvism, orphists, synchronists).

[…] You noted this effort directed towards the new construction of colour at once mysterious and profound. […] It is one long series of studies of form expressed in light or lights (prism) of the sun, moon, gas, electricity, etc., by means of simultaneous contrasts of colour. The point of departure for these painters is the objective study of colour, of the laws that govern colours – as in music there are laws of sounds. Each creator, each discoverer carries in him the innovations that come to augment the universal patrimony of Art.”(Batchelor, 2008: 68-69)

 

 

Robert Delaunay - Window, 1912-13

Movement and colour were the starting points for a subsequent dance improvisation video art installation project. Painting offered another reference in Duchamp’s groundbreaking for his contemporaries Nude descending a staircase (1912), where movement is formalised as broken-down elements of the human figure in motion, which takes place in time and space. Duchamp set out to break with the naturalist tradition of painting an object to elevate painting into a plastic art that creates its own plastic art reality: a painting is an object with its own plastic identity, it doesn’t need to depict something (Read, 1974: 126). For this reason, he used brown hues minimally to give a sculptural quality to his painting.

For the video art interactive installation,

I exploited the artistic view of breaking-down, slowing down, as well as freezing the dancers’ movement for the installation projection that was watched at the same time as the choreographed performance was taking place. The video art installation did not depict the dancers’ performance; it was rather a stand-alone visual art project that accompanied in a conceptually complementary manner the dance performance. I kept colour as a referent to the naturalistic element of physical movement.

Dance improvisation, especially contact improvisation, exploits the continuously changing distance between two or more dancers to develop and build on choreographic techniques for their physical interaction, which often involves sharing the weight of one or more dancers with their dance partners. How the dancer works with the physical borders of other performers is crucial to a successful dance improvisation. Like in my painting, there are always parts of the choreography that are not decided from the beginning, but are continuously created and improvised as the dance unfolds.

 

creating borders

with movement

isolated part for larger painting

Sketch of Cezanne's 'The Bathers' (1906), 2011

For the apartment renovation, structured around a series of small rooms, I concentrated on creating movement in the interior space, by making new openings, but also allowing for the possibility of closing off or opening up areas through the use of new and existing doors. Coming through the openings, light, as well as sounds from the neighbourhood, were deployed to give a sense of transparency and liveliness in the interior. Again, light and sounds could be blocked off at will, creating natural fluid borders between the different spaces. This option was achieved by maintaining the traditional shutters and by soundproofing all timber frames. The apartment’s central area, which was the dullest before the renovation, was fitted with glass coloured panels to isolate different uses and to serve as a door. New coloured storage space made usable an unused hallway recession and completed the colourfull spatial composition. The view to the back courtyard with a growing palm tree was given special importance; I filled in with glass blocks the openings with the uninteresting views.

Taking language and form as my initial points of reference for discussing “colour’s nature and value” (Batchelor, 2008: 19), bearing in mind that colour has also been associated with the property of some “foreign” body (Batchelor, 2008: 221), in this three-partite exposition, I discussed problems of interpretation and systematisation of environmentally directed beliefs, with reference to my painting work, as well as two separate projects: a video art installation and an architectural renovation. Apart from art historical references on modern painting, I drew from Davidson’s philosophical work on action as the theoretical framework for rethinking questions of interpretation derived from environmentally directed beliefs. My intention was to rethink broadly the actions of making and interpreting artworks as distinct, but also interrelated activities. 

           In the above theoretical framework, I want to argue for taking art as propositional, revising the cognitive aesthetic claim that art is traditionally taken to be non-propositional. I have examined whether environmentally directed beliefs and conceptual schemes organise in such a manner as to account for art's propositionality. With this in mind, by employing Davidson’s philosophy of action for analysing questions of interpretation derived from environmentally directed beliefs, I have discussed problems of systematisation and interpretation of environmentally directed beliefs. I concluded that questions of meaning and interpretation in the context of environmentally directed beliefs need not be examined as epistemic, or as empirical questions; but rather, if we were to adopt Davidsonian principles, in terms of theories of coherence taken together with correspondence. I suggest that theories of coherence with theories of correspondence can offer the starting point for thinking art as propositional beyond the traditional cognitive aesthetic claim. Conceptual schemes and environmentally directed beliefs help us think of art as system, rather than as language, to account for art’s propositionality. In the above context, I showed that the action of making and the action of interpreting artworks are distinct, yet intimately interconnected activities. 

 

Art's propositionality

NAVIGATE

References

Batchelor, David (ed.), Colour. “Documents of Contemporary Art”, London: Whitechapel, Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press, 2008.

Blackburn, Simon, Spreading the Word: Groundings in the Philosophy of Language, Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1984.

Cezanne, Paul, Correspondence, John Rewald (ed.), London: Bernard Grasset, 1941.

Davidson, Donald, "Reply to Foster", Truth and Meaning, G. Evans and J. McDowell (eds.), Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1976, 33-41.

Davidson, Donald, "On the Very Idea of a Conceptual Scheme" (1974), Inquiries into Truth and Interpretation, Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1984, 183-198.

Davidson, Donald, "A Coherence Theory of Truth and Knowledge" (1983), Subjective, Intersubjective, Objective, Oxford: Clarendon Press, 2001, 137-157.

Davidson, Donald, "The Second Person" (1992), Subjective, Intersubjective, Objective, Oxford: Clarendon Press, 2001, 107-121.

Read, Herbert, A Concise History of Modern Painting, London: Thames & Hudson, 2nd edition, 1974.

Wittgenstein, Ludwig, On Certainty, G.E.M. Anscombe and D.H. von Wright (eds.). Oxford: Blackwell, 1969.