Exposition

Finding Focus (2019)

Susan Williams
no media files associated
open exposition
1

About this exposition

An important question facing musicians both in the practice room and on stage is “What should I focus on?” There is a great deal of research in the fields of movement sciences and sports that suggests that adopting an external focus of attention – focusing on the intended effects of one’s movements – can be beneficial both for learning and for performance of complex motor skills. There has been very little research done on the effects of external focus on musicians. The aims of this study on external focus were as follows: to translate the idea of external focus from movement science into the field of music (how can external focus be characterized for music-making?); to design several ways to use, test and explore the application of external focus in field situations; and to collect data and find information to elucidate the effects of external focus and the instances in which it can work for musicians. A series of three empirical projects were designed and carried out in both semi-controlled as well as natural environments. The mixed methods research approach included both quantitative and qualitative elements. A music-pedagogical practice tool based on external focus was designed and used in all three projects. The first project involved natural trumpet players (n=7) who practiced fragments of repertoire using an external focus practice tool. Results were compared the their ‘usual’ practice methods. Quantitative data was collected to show the effects of external focus on accuracy, self-efficacy, confidence and motivation of the players. In the second project the same seven players participated in the preparation and performance of a chamber music concert for trumpet consort. The third project involved a chamber ensemble of 18 players including string players, trumpeters and keyboard players. In projects two and three the performances were prepared and rehearsed by using tools and techniques based on external focus. Qualitative data was collected from questionnaires, surveys and interviews. Results from the three projects tentatively supported the overall hypothesis: External focus is beneficial to musicians’ learning and performance experience. Statistical results showed positive effects of external focus on accuracy and suggest a positive trend for confidence and for self-efficacy in performance. Qualitative data from interviews and surveys over the three interventions showed the performers’ ensemble playing was enhanced by using an external focus approach, and that they suffered much less from performance anxiety than usual. External focus could play a larger role in music pedagogy for musicians at every level and stage of learning. The kind of procedural implicit learning that results from using tools based on external focus means that technique (motor control) is being informed by musical intention and not the other way around.
typeresearch exposition
keywordsExternal focus, Musicians's motor learning, Attentional focus, Musical imagery
date29/01/2019
published19/09/2019
last modified19/09/2019
statuspublished
share statusprivate
affiliationLeiden University
licenseAll rights reserved
urlhttps://www.researchcatalogue.net/view/497578/497694
published inAcademy of Creative and Performing Arts
portal issue2019. 2019
connected toAcademy of Creative and Performing Arts


Simple Media

id name copyright license
497587 Figure 1.1 SW All rights reserved
497616 FIgure 1.2 SW All rights reserved
497666 Stages of learning_pdf SW All rights reserved
497669 Stages of learning_pdf SW All rights reserved
497697 IMG_0615_holistic diagram SW All rights reserved
497699 4-3_focus_color-2 SW All rights reserved
497793 Stages of learning_JPEG SW All rights reserved
497795 Stages of learning_JPEG SW All rights reserved
497840 Figure 1.1_JPEG SW All rights reserved
498101 farbkreis-voll_gross SW All rights reserved
498132 farbkreis-voll_klein SW All rights reserved
498134 farbkreis-G_klein SW All rights reserved
498136 farbkreis-CMY_klein SW All rights reserved
498176 farbkreis-voll_klein SW All rights reserved
498178 farbkreis-weiss_klein SW All rights reserved
498182 farbkreis-G_klein SW All rights reserved
498184 farbkreis-B_klein SW All rights reserved
498186 farbkreis-R_klein SW All rights reserved
498188 farbkreis-CMY_klein SW All rights reserved
498190 farbkreis-RGB_klein SW All rights reserved
498192 farbkreis-RGBCMY_klein SW All rights reserved
498663 farbkreis-B_grau_7 SW All rights reserved
498665 farbkreis-CMY_grau_3 SW All rights reserved
498667 farbkreis-G_grau_5 SW All rights reserved
498669 farbkreis-R_grau_6 SW All rights reserved
498671 farbkreis-RGB_grau_2 SW All rights reserved
500703 Natural trpt Pic SW All rights reserved
500715 Figure 0.2 SW All rights reserved
500725 Fig. 0.3_1 SW All rights reserved
500729 FIg 0.3_2 SW All rights reserved
500788 Figure 10.1 SW All rights reserved
500795 QUALITY PRACTICE Musician's Manual SW All rights reserved
500796 musicians_manual_online_EN SW All rights reserved
501208 From 1b SW All rights reserved
501210 From 1b_2 SW All rights reserved
501212 From 2a SW All rights reserved
501214 From 2b_1 SW All rights reserved
501216 From 2b_2 SW All rights reserved
501218 From 4b SW All rights reserved
504550 Test piece_2b_fragment SW All rights reserved
504558 7_BAch a) SW All rights reserved
505559 Fig 1.1- Skills tree SW All rights reserved
505561 Fig 1.1- Skills tree_JPEG SW All rights reserved
505668 Fig. 1.2. OPTIMAL diag SW All rights reserved
505670 Fig1.2 OPTIMAL diag SW All rights reserved
506635 Figure 5.2 SW All rights reserved
506973 Dragonfly SW All rights reserved
507046 Dragonfly SW All rights reserved
507604 Figure 5.3_new SW All rights reserved
507611 Figure 5.4_new SW All rights reserved
507616 Figure 5.5_new SW All rights reserved
507623 Figure 5.6_new SW All rights reserved
507629 FIgure 5.7_new SW All rights reserved
507730 Macht und Musik SW All rights reserved
507732 BIBER_wordcloud_png SW All rights reserved
507742 Figure 7.1a SW All rights reserved
507744 Figure 7.1b SW All rights reserved
507746 Figure 7.1c SW All rights reserved
507748 Figure 7.1d SW All rights reserved
507765 Gestures SW All rights reserved
507770 FIgure 6.1 SW All rights reserved
507776 FIgure 6.2 SW All rights reserved
507801 Figure 6.3 SW All rights reserved
507808 FIgure 6.4 SW All rights reserved
507813 FIgure 6.5 SW All rights reserved
507818 Figure 6.6 SW All rights reserved
507834 Bremen Concert 2_JPEG SW All rights reserved
507835 Bremen Concert 1 SW All rights reserved
507836 Bremen Concert 3 SW All rights reserved
507837 Bremen Concert 6 SW All rights reserved
507839 Macht und Musik SW All rights reserved
507840 PPT2 SW All rights reserved
507841 PPT3 SW All rights reserved
507842 PPT4 SW All rights reserved
507843 PPT5 SW All rights reserved
507845 PPT6 SW All rights reserved
507846 PPT7 SW All rights reserved
507847 PPT8 SW All rights reserved
507849 PPT9 SW All rights reserved
507850 PPT10 SW All rights reserved
507851 PPT11 SW All rights reserved
507852 PPT12 SW All rights reserved
507854 PPT13 SW All rights reserved
507860 PPT14 SW All rights reserved
507861 PPT15 SW All rights reserved
507862 PPT16 SW All rights reserved
507863 PPT17 SW All rights reserved
507864 PPT18 SW All rights reserved
507865 PPT19 SW All rights reserved
507866 PPT20 SW All rights reserved
507867 PPT21 SW All rights reserved
507868 PPT22 SW All rights reserved
507869 Gestures 3_practising musical intention SW All rights reserved
507897 BIBER_wordcloud_png SW All rights reserved
507898 Figure 7.1d SW All rights reserved
507899 Figure 7.1a SW All rights reserved
507900 Figure 7.1b SW All rights reserved
507901 Figure 7.1c SW All rights reserved
507902 Biber_lecture1 SW All rights reserved
507903 Biber_lecture3 SW All rights reserved
507904 Biber_lecture4 SW All rights reserved
507905 Biber _lecture2 SW All rights reserved
507907 Cesare Ripa SW All rights reserved
507908 Biber_bodywork SW All rights reserved
507909 Biber_rehearsal1 SW All rights reserved
507910 Biber _rehearsal2 SW All rights reserved
507911 Biber dressreh_1 SW All rights reserved
507912 BIber _dressreh2 SW All rights reserved
507913 Biber_dressreh.3 SW All rights reserved
507914 Biber_trumpeters SW All rights reserved
507918 BIBER_wordcloud_png SW All rights reserved
508024 piece1A SW All rights reserved
508504 PieceA2 SW All rights reserved
508507 PieceA3 SW All rights reserved
508510 PieceA4 SW All rights reserved
508514 PieceB1 SW All rights reserved
508523 PieceB2 SW All rights reserved
508527 PieceB3 SW All rights reserved
508532 PieceB4 SW All rights reserved
508541 Sight-reading piece SW All rights reserved
508800 Coding_interview Project 2_to export SW All rights reserved
508821 Program booklet Biber-2016_pdf SW All rights reserved
508826 BIBER SCHEDULE_pdf SW All rights reserved
508828 Appendix W SW All rights reserved
511084 Dragonfly SW All rights reserved
533012 james WK All rights reserved
533013 Natural Trumpet-4 Susan Williams All rights reserved
533015 Natural Trumpet-4 Casper Schipper 2018 All rights reserved
534016 Fragment 1 SW All rights reserved
534019 Frag 1 SW All rights reserved
534023 Frag1 SW All rights reserved
534025 Frag1 SW All rights reserved
534027 Frag1_new SW All rights reserved
534029 Frag1_new SW All rights reserved
534031 Frag2_new SW All rights reserved
534034 Frag3_new SW All rights reserved
534036 Frag4_new SW All rights reserved
534038 Frag5_new SW All rights reserved
537968 Bach edited SW All rights reserved
537972 1_APT_3a_pre_19 Mar 2015 RC SW All rights reserved
537974 1_APT_3a_post_23 Mar 2015 RC SW All rights reserved
601920 Figure-1.1_pdf Susan Williams All rights reserved
601928 Figure-1.1_pdf Susan Williams All rights reserved

comments: 1 (last entry by Michiel Schuijer - 12/11/2018 at 00:32)
Michiel Schuijer 12/11/2018 at 00:32

The comment was deleted by Michiel Schuijer on 12/11/2018 at 00:33.
Comments are only available for registered users.


i have forgotten my password
join the research catalogue
Portals The research catalogue serves:
Journal for Artistic Research
a peer-reviewed international journal for all art disciplines
KC Research Portal
Research Portal of the Royal Conservatoire, The Hague
Norwegian Artistic Research Programme
The portal of the Norwegian Artistic Research Programme
RUUKKU - Studies in Artistic Research
Taiteellisen tutkimuksen kausijulkaisu / Studies in Artistic Research
University of Applied Arts Vienna
RC portal of the University of Applied Arts Vienna
Journal of Sonic Studies
A peer-reviewed, international journal on sound studies and auditory culture
Academy of Creative and Performing Arts
Portal of the Academy of Creative and Performing Arts, Leiden University
SHAPE - Artistic Research and Institutional Impact
SHAPE aims to describe the impact of artistic research within specific frameworks.
Faculty of Fine Art, Music and Design, University of Bergen
Portal of Faculty of Fine Art, Music and Design
Polifonia
Polifonia
Codarts
Portal of Codarts, University of the Arts, Rotterdam
Stockholm University of the Arts
Stockholm University of the Arts (Uniarts) provides education and conducts research in the fields of choreography, film & media, opera and performing arts.
University of the Arts Helsinki
University of the Arts Helsinki was launched in 2013 upon the merging of the Finnish Academy of Fine Arts, Sibelius Academy, and Theatre Academy Helsinki.
Norwegian Academy of Music
A leading artistic and academic university college with approximately 700 students. Located in Oslo, Norway.
The Danish National School of Performing Arts
This portal is a platform for distribution of knowledge produced through artistic research at the Danish National School of Performing Arts.
VIS – Nordic Journal for Artistic Research
VIS – Nordic Journal for Artistic Research
Rhythmic Music Conservatory Copenhagen
The portal of Rhythmic Music Conservatory Copenhagen
Konstfack – University of Arts, Crafts and Design
Konstfack – University of Arts, Crafts and Design, Stockholm