Exposition

‘Who creates the creator’ – and the limits of interpretation? (2011)

Anders Hultqvist
no media files associated
open exposition
1

About this exposition

In this presentation I will discuss some associative thoughts and preliminary results arising in connection with the forthcoming production of new stage-settings of Beethoven’s Fifth Symphony and Albinoni’s ‘Adagio’. The goal is to re-read and re-set the music and relieve it from some of the cultural layers and interpretational rituals that conventionally have been assigned to the pieces. The first part of the title, ‘Who creates the creator?’, refers to a question raised by Pierre Bourdieu in relation to in whose interest the present interpretational tradition is upheld? Is it for the sake of the art object or just for upholding the business around virtuosity and the genius? I want to bring forward a slightly different story, and this from within the musical material. Both of the works are exceedingly well known and are in different ways incorporated in our cultural canon. Beethoven’s Fifth Symphony is seen as the overall emblematic piece for the whole classical tradition. Albinoni’s Adagio on the other hand plays a different role in the cultural landscape and addresses nostalgia in a more direct manner. “A musician, as is obvious, must, in the Western musical tradition, know how to intelligently read a score… For once one leaves meaning-interpretation for — what shall I call it? — structure-interpretation, the spell of monism is broken. Why shouldn’t a structure have more than one interpretation, more than one way it goes?” This citation from philosopher Peter Kivy can be widened, I will show, to also include the interpretation of form within a piece of music. By presenting two, in a way opposite, interpretational strategies in the same concert program, there is a larger possibility than is usually the case, for the audience and the musicians to start reflecting on the question of musical interpretation in a broader sense. With orchestras around the world relentlessly upholding the classical and romantic tradition in their repertoire there is a great need for new interpretational angles. The two new interpretations are to be performed by the Gothenburg Symphony Orchestra in October 2011.
typeresearch exposition
date01/01/2011
published20/11/2011
last modified15/10/2012
statuspublished
licenseAll rights reserved
urlhttps://www.researchcatalogue.net/view/8563/8838
doihttps://doi.org/10.22501/jar.8563
published inJournal for Artistic Research
portal issue0.


Simple Media

id name copyright license
9054 Pict1Sontag Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
9055 Pict1Sontag Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
9053 Adagietto ending Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
9050 pict5 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
9051 pict15 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
9048 pict6 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
9049 pict4 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
9047 pict7 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
9034 pict8 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
9031 yellow_hammer Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
9032 pict9 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
9033 pict8 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
9029 pict12 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
9030 pict11 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
9027 pict14 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
9028 pict13 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
9025 score1 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
9019 pict20 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
9020 pict19 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
9017 Pict24 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
9018 pict23 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
9015 pict26 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
9016 pict25 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
9013 pict29 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
9014 pict27 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
9011 pict32 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
9012 pict31 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
9009 pict34 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
9052 Beethovens 5th and Albinoni's Adagio 2011 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
9037 txt9 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
9038 txt8 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
9039 txt7 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
9040 txt6 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
9041 txt16 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
9042 txt14 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
9043 txt5 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
9044 txt4 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
9045 txt3 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
9046 txt1 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
9035 txt11 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
9036 txt10 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
9026 Link soundfile - yellow hammer Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
9022 wwww Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
9023 txt13 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
9024 txt12 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
9021 Title Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
9010 pict33 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
9007 pict17 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
9008 pict15 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
9005 pict2a Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
9006 pict1 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
9004 pict3a Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
9001 pict12a Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
9002 pict9a Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
9003 pict7a Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8999 pict22a Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
9000 pict17a Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8997 pict18a Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8998 pict28a Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8996 pict21a Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8995 pict30a Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8994 pict13b Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8989 pict37 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8987 pict15d Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8988 pict38 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8982 pict40 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8990 txt17 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8991 who creates the creator? Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8992 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8993 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8981 txt20 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8983 txt19 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8984 txt18 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8985 txt15 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8986 txt14 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8980 Adagio middle section Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8976 kandinsky2 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8979 on the square Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8949 maqam Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8977 P Bourdieu Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8978 S Sontag Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8965 Binding movements Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8966 L van B, a young Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8967 Fig.1 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8968 shortened 1,2,3... Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8969 1,2,3 take off Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8970 New bridge Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8971 Orig.Beethoven Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8972 S Sontag3 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8973 Y Hammer Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8974 P Kivy Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8975 Kandinsky Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8955 txt The pleading Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8956 txt Albinoni-Mahler Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8957 txt Mahler ending Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8958 Albinoni last section Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8959 txt Adagio middle section Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8960 Taqsim Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8961 Albinoni middle section Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8962 Albinoni Intro Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8963 a new staging Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8964 txt 1,2,3 and... Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8950 txt E-mail corr Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8951 Abstract Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8952 txt Albinoni picture Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8953 txt Doors video Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8954 txt soundscape Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8948 txt2 e-mail corr Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8945 txt (de)construction Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8946 Czerny anecdote Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8947 scorepict B5th2 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8944 usit Jarntorget Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8943 melancholy Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8941 and Albinoni's Adagio Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8940 Arrows Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8942 Kandinsky-Beethoven 3 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8938 Adagiored.ver Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8939 Arrow pict Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8936 B5ared.version Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8937 Yellow Hammer 3 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8935 Beethoven 5 formal sketch Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8931 Empty corner Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8932 Sounding example Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8933 Albinoni strategies Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8934 Beethoven 5 jpeg formal sketch Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8930 Albinoni example 1 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8926 score new setting 123...a Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8927 ninent Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8928 ninent Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8929 Albinoni example 2 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8925 pict16Orig score Symph.No5i Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8923 End argument beethoven Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8924 pict16Orig score Symph.No5h Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8922 score3a Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8921 score4a Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8920 Beethoven 1 Movement Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8919 Beethoven New Bridge Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8918 Beethoven 1,2,3 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8917 Beethoven new 1,2,3 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8916 Adagietto Ending Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8915 ddd Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8628 pict31 #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8626 Albinoni/Giazotto's Adagio - intro #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8618 Albinoni's Adagio - last section #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8616 Albinoni's Adagio - middle section #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8614 Mahler's Adagietto - ending #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8612 Taqsim on Violin #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8610 The pleading of... #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8608 Melancholic landscapes: urban and musical artefacts #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8606 pict32 #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8604 pict33 #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8600 Arrow pict #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8602 usit Jarntorget #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8598 Albinoni example 2 #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8596 Albinoni example 1 #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8594 pict36 #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8592 pict39 #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8580 maqam #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8570 Doors video #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8735 pict23 #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8733 pict20 #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8731 pict19 #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8727 pict26 #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8729 pict27 #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8725 pict25 #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8723 Pict24 #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8717 pict29 #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8719 pict31 #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8721 pict32 #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8715 pict34 #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8710 pict30a #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8712 pict33 #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8713 pict33 #1 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8708 pict21a #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8704 pict28a #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8706 pict18a #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8702 pict22a #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8698 Adagio-last section #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8700 The pleading of... #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8694 Adagio-intro #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8696 Taqsim on Violin #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8692 pict37 #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8687 pict36 #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8688 pict36 #1 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8689 pict36 #2 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8690 pict36 #3 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8683 Adagietto-last section #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8685 pict31 #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8676 pict38 #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8678 pict39 #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8679 pict39 #1 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8674 Doors video #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8672 Adagio middle section #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8664 on the square #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8662 Fiskekyran #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8642 maqam #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8779 pict17a #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8781 Ending first movement, start second movement #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8777 New bridge from first to second movement #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8775 A shortening of the '1, 2, 3 and take off' #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8773 A typical '1, 2, 3 and take off' #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8765 pict15d #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8755 Beethoven 5 jpeg formal sketch #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8750 Beethoven 1 Movement #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8751 Beethoven 1 Movement #1 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8745 Beethoven New Bridge #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8746 Beethoven New Bridge #1 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8747 Beethoven New Bridge #2 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8748 Beethoven New Bridge #3 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8741 Beethoven 1,2,3 #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8742 Beethoven 1,2,3 #1 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8743 Beethoven 1,2,3 #2 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8738 Beethoven new 1,2,3 #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8739 Beethoven new 1,2,3 #1 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8825 pict14 #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8821 pict11 #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8823 pict13 #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8819 pict8 #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8814 pict13b #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8815 pict13b #1 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8810 pict12a #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8812 pict10 #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8808 pict9a #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8804 pict40 #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8802 Yellow Hammer #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8796 Adagio f relax #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8800 H Lidbo Beethoven remix #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8908 pict7a #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8896 pict40 #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8876 pict12a #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8878 pict10 #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8880 pict14 #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8882 pict11 #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8874 pict13 #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8866 scorepict B5th2 #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8864 pict13b #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8860 Albinoni's Adagio - Opening #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8862 H Lidbo Beethoven remix #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8858 Kandinsky-Beethoven 3 #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8852 Beethoven's Fifth - Opening #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8850 Yellow Hammer #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8842 P Bourdieu2 #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
8840 Beethoven HERO 2 #0 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
391944 beethoven1 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
391945 clockwork Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
391946 formal_sketch Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
391947 williamAnsanati Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
391948 Hlibdoremix Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
391949 allegro-con-brio Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
391950 beethoven-directs Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
391951 yellow_hammer Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
391952 horlogemaker Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
391953 richard-iii Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
391957 albinoni Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
391958 Doors-AlbinoniAdagio Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
391959 melancholia Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
391960 plein Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
391961 little-score Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
391965 arrwos Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
391966 Taqsim on Violin Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
391967 hulqvist Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
391969 Adagiored.ver Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
391970 Beethoven 1-2 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
391971 Beethoven new bridge1-2-2 Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
391974 Beethoven 1-2-TL Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
391975 Beethoven new bridge1-2-TR Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
391976 Beethoven 3(1,2.3 and...)_bl Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved
391977 Beethoven new 1,2,3...BR Anders Hultqvist All rights reserved

Comments are only available for registered users.


i have forgotten my password
join the research catalogue
Portals The research catalogue serves:
Journal for Artistic Research
a peer-reviewed international journal for all art disciplines
KC Research Portal
Research Portal of the Royal Conservatoire, The Hague
Norwegian Artistic Research Programme
The portal of the Norwegian Artistic Research Programme
RUUKKU - Studies in Artistic Research
Taiteellisen tutkimuksen kausijulkaisu / Studies in Artistic Research
University of Applied Arts Vienna
RC portal of the University of Applied Arts Vienna
Journal of Sonic Studies
A peer-reviewed, international journal on sound studies and auditory culture
Academy of Creative and Performing Arts
Portal of the Academy of Creative and Performing Arts, Leiden University
SHAPE - Artistic Research and Institutional Impact
SHAPE aims to describe the impact of artistic research within specific frameworks.
Faculty of Fine Art, Music and Design, University of Bergen
Portal of Faculty of Fine Art, Music and Design
Polifonia
Polifonia
Codarts
Portal of Codarts, University of the Arts, Rotterdam
Stockholm University of the Arts
Stockholm University of the Arts (Uniarts) provides education and conducts research in the fields of choreography, film & media, opera and performing arts.
University of the Arts Helsinki
University of the Arts Helsinki was launched in 2013 upon the merging of the Finnish Academy of Fine Arts, Sibelius Academy, and Theatre Academy Helsinki.
Norwegian Academy of Music
A leading artistic and academic university college with over 600 students. Located in Oslo, Norway.
The Danish National School of Performing Arts
This portal is a platform for distribution of knowledge produced through artistic research at the Danish National School of Performing Arts.
VIS – Nordic Journal for Artistic Research
VIS – Nordic Journal for Artistic Research
Rhythmic Music Conservatory Copenhagen
The portal of Rhythmic Music Conservatory Copenhagen
Konstfack – University of Arts, Crafts and Design
Konstfack – University of Arts, Crafts and Design, Stockholm
Interested in setting up your own portal?