Propositions for Unfinished Thinking: The Research Score as a Medium of Artistic Research

Joa Hug

Exposition

Propositions for Unfinished Thinking: The Research Score as a Medium of Artistic Research (2020)

Joa Hug

open exposition

About this exposition

This research exposition presents the process and results of the author’s doctoral research at the Performing Arts Research Centre of the Theatre Academy at the University of the Arts Helsinki, and is the final written part—the commentary—to fulfil the degree requirements. The research tackled the division between embodied and conceptual modes of reflection – a problem that is considered a key challenge for research into performer training. Crafted around Body Weather performance training, the research explored the epistemic potential of a touch-based body practice called the Manipulations, and engendered the transformation of this practice into a medium of artistic research—the research score—which is both the main method and the outcome of the research. In the commentary, the research score is considered to be a way of facilitating unfinished thinking that dissolves the division between physical practice and conceptual reflection, and which enables a shift from a representational towards a post-humanist performative model of knowing. Unfinished thinking is not the property of an individual, intentional, agential subject, but emerges from within an expanded network of inter-corporeal relations; it expresses thought without uncoupling language from its affective tonality, and it defies definite statements. The commentary covers a broad range of theoretical considerations on embodiment, materiality, (bodily) knowledge, technique, and reflection, and thus contributes to the debate on the epistemology and methodology of artistic research. Combining analytical and descriptive forms of scholarly writing with performative modes of experimental writing, the commentary expands the format of academic dissertation writing and offers new knowledge to the fields of dance (research), performance (research), performer training, and artistic research. Tiivistelmä Tässä kirjallisessa työssä esitellään kirjoittajan väitöskirjatutkimuksen tulokset ja tutkimusprosessin kulku, ja se toimii samalla tohtorintutkinnon tutkintovaatimusten viimeisenä, kirjallisena osana – kommentaarina. Tutkimus on tehty Taideyliopiston Teatterikorkeakoulun Esittävien taiteiden tutkimuskeskuksessa, ja se pureutuu kehollisen ja käsitteellisen reflektion välillä yleisesti tehtyyn jaotteluun – käytäntöön, joka muodostuu merkittäväksi haasteeksi esiintyjäkoulutusta käsittelevässä tutkimuksessa. Väitöskirjatutkimus perustuu pitkälti Body Weather esityskoulutukseen, ja siinä tarkastellaan manipulaatioiksi kutsuttujen, kosketukseen perustuvien kehollisten käytäntöjen episteemistä potentiaalia. Näistä käytännöistä kootaan taiteellisen tutkimuksen väline—tutkimus-score—josta muodostuu sekä tärkein tutkimuksessa käytetty menetelmä että sen merkittävin tutkimustulos. Tutkimus-score esitellään kommentaarissa tapana, joka edistää keskeneräisiä ajatusprosesseja ja tekee turhaksi jaottelun fyysisen toiminnan ja käsitteellisen reflektion välillä. Score mahdollistaa myös representaationaalisten tietomallien korvaamisen posthumanistisilla, performatiivisilla malleilla. Keskeneräistä ajattelua ei pidetä työssä yksittäisen, intentionaalisen ja agentiivisen subjektin ominaisuutena, vaan se nousee esiin kehonvälisten suhteiden laajennetusta verkostosta: siinä ilmaistaan ajatuksia tavalla, jossa kieltä ei eroteta sen affektiivisista sävyistä, ja näin ollen sitä on vaikea tarkoin määritellä. Kommentaarissa käsitellään kattavasti kehollisuutta, materiaalisuutta, (kehollista) tietoa, tekniikkaa ja reflektiota eri teoreettisista näkökulmista, ja tällä tavoin se muodostuu osaksi taiteentutkimuksen epistemologista ja metodologista keskustelua. Tieteellisen kirjoittamisen analyyttiset ja kuvailevat muodot yhdistyvät kommentaarissa kokeellisen kirjoittamisen esittäviin tapoihin. Työ monipuolistaa täten akateemisen väitöskirjan toteuttamistapoja ja tarjoaa uutta tietoa tanssin (tanssintutkimuksen), esityksen (esityksen tutkimuksen), esiintyjäkoulutuksen ja taiteentutkimuksen aloilta. Colophon: Joa Hug Propositions for Unfinished Thinking: The Research Score as a Medium of Artistic Research DOCTORAL RESEARCH Acta Scenica 59, 2020 ISBN: 978-952-353-026-3 ISSN: 2242-6485 PUBLISHER: University of the Arts Helsinki, Theatre Academy, Performing Arts Research Centre © 2020 University of the Arts Helsinki, Theatre Academy, Performing Arts Research Centre and Joa Hug

type	research exposition
keywords	Performer Training, dance, Body Weather, Embodied reflection, experimental writing, unfinished thinking, research score, doctoral thesis
date	08/02/2018
published	08/09/2020
last modified	08/09/2020
status	published
affiliation	Performing Arts Research Centre, University of the Arts Helsinki/Theatre Academy
copyright	University of the Arts Helsinki, Theatre Academy, Performing Arts Research Centre and Joa Hug
license	All rights reserved
url	https://www.researchcatalogue.net/view/433112/596407
published in	University of the Arts Helsinki
portal issue	2020.

Copyrights

name	Exam_2_Rescore_War_RC_converted.MPEG-4
copyright	Joa Hug 2018
license	All rights reserved
usages	video, video

name	Audio_05032016_rescore_diffraction_RC_03142018
copyright	Joa Hug 2018
license	All rights reserved
usages	audio

name	Diffraction original 2000 x 8100
copyright	Joa Hug 2018
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Audio_05312016_rescore_knowhow_RC_03132018
copyright	Joa Hug 2018
license	All rights reserved
usages	audio

name	Still Rescore Knowhow 170 x 500
copyright	Joa Hug 2018
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Still Rescore Knowhow 1700 x 3000
copyright	Joa Hug 2018
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Audio_rescore_0602&0603_03062016
copyright	Joa Hug 2018
license	All rights reserved
usages	audio

name	Rescore Crosscut Floor 1500 x 15000
copyright	Joa Hug 2018
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Cover Manips Rescore copy
copyright	Joa Hug 2018
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Audio_09272016_Manipulations_reflecting with_difference_12042017_Edit_redesigned
copyright	Joa Hug 2018
license	All rights reserved
usages	audio

name	Cover Re Difference 2500 x 12750
copyright	Joa Hug 2018
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Rescore_difference_Comp_11102017
copyright	Joa Hug
license	All rights reserved
usages	audio

name	Background Translation copy 2
copyright	Joa Hug 2018
license	All rights reserved
usages	background, background

name	Cover Translation copy
copyright	Joa Hug 2018
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture, background

name	09272016_Rescore_Translation1&2_12122017_Edit_designed_short
copyright	Joa Hug 2018
license	All rights reserved
usages	audio

name	Translation TSD 3
copyright	Joa Hug 2018
license	All rights reserved
usages	video

name	Cover rescore with rescore copy
copyright	Joa Hug 2018
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Audio_07012016_Afternoon_03162016
copyright	Joa Hug 2018
license	All rights reserved
usages	audio

name	Listening
copyright	Hug 2012
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Installing
copyright	H
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Maintaining
copyright	Hug 2012
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Manipulating
copyright	Hug 2012
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Minimal MT
copyright	Hug 2012
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Monitoring
copyright	Hug 2012
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Negotiating
copyright	Hug 2012
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Negotiating 2
copyright	Hug 2012
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Observing
copyright	Hug 2012
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Observing 2
copyright	Hug 2012
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Peeling Off
copyright	Hug 2012
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Handling
copyright	Hug 2012
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Holding
copyright	Hug 2012
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Giving
copyright	Hug 2012
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Flow
copyright	Hug 2012
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Effort
copyright	Hug 2012
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	dissecting
copyright	Hug 2012
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Cutting
copyright	Hug 2012
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Camera
copyright	Hug 2012
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Availability
copyright	Hug 2012
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Autopilot
copyright	Hug 2012
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Allowing
copyright	Hug 2012
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Reading
copyright	Hug 2012
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Receiving
copyright	Hug 2012
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Resisting
copyright	Hug 2012
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Scanning
copyright	Hug 2012
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Stand-by
copyright	Hug 2012
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Surrendering
copyright	Hug 2012
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Fixing
copyright	Hug 2012
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Research Score RC 2
copyright	Hug
license	All rights reserved
usages	video

name	Switching Off
copyright	Hug 2012
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Towards
copyright	Hug 2012
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Transposing
copyright	Hug 2012
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	tunnel perception
copyright	Hug 2012
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Undoing
copyright	Hug 2012
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Registration Exam 2012 for RC
copyright	Hug 2012
license	All rights reserved
usages	video

name	Glossary Original
copyright	Hug 2012
license	All rights reserved
usages	pdf

name	Program
copyright	Hug 2012
license	All rights reserved
usages	pdf

name	Computer back
copyright	Hug 2012
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Computer
copyright	Hug 2012
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Diagonal left
copyright	Hug 2012
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture, picture, picture

name	Diagonal right
copyright	Hug 2012
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	MP1 full quality
copyright	Hug 2008
license	All rights reserved
usages	video, video

name	Research Proposal Joa Hug 0911
copyright	Hug 2011
license	All rights reserved
usages	pdf

name	Abstract HPT JHug
copyright	Hug 2012
license	All rights reserved
usages	pdf

name	CIMG4651
copyright	Hug 2012
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Workshop flyer
copyright	Hug 2012
license	All rights reserved
usages	pdf

name	Manipulations
copyright	Joa Hug 2008
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture, picture

name	Research Score
copyright	Joa Hug 2016
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture, picture

name	Linking Paper
copyright	Hug 2012
license	All rights reserved
usages	pdf

name	Abstract Presentation JHug
copyright	Hug 2013
license	All rights reserved
usages	pdf

name	CIMG4908
copyright	Hug 2012
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	CIMG4907
copyright	Hug 2013
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	CIMG4910
copyright	Hug 2013
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	AREAL_REV
copyright	Hug 2013
license	All rights reserved
usages	pdf

name	Program Dance Congress
copyright	Hug 2013
license	All rights reserved
usages	pdf

name	Ploebst Report The new knowledge
copyright	Dance Congress
license	All rights reserved
usages	pdf

name	Tanzkongress Paula 1
copyright	Hug 2012
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Tanzkongress Paula 2
copyright	Hug 2012
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Tanzkongress Paula 3
copyright	Hug 2012
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Tanzkongress Paula 4
copyright	Hug 2012
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Joa Tanzkongress 1
copyright	Hug 2012
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Joa Tanzkongress 2
copyright	Hug 2012
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Joa Tanzkongress 3
copyright	Hug 2012
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Joa Tanzkongress 4
copyright	Hug 2012
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Wrap-up Nelson
copyright	Hug 2012
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Workshop Helsinki Joint Studies
copyright	Hug 2013
license	All rights reserved
usages	pdf

name	New Visions on Dance poster
copyright	Hug 2012
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Diffraction
copyright	Joa Hug 2008
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Still Rescore Knowhow
copyright	Joa Hug 2016
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Rescore Crosscut Floor 2
copyright	Joa Hug 2018
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Cover Manips Rescore
copyright	Joa Hug 2016
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	RS difference
copyright	Joa Hug 2016
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Cover rescore with rescore
copyright	Joa Hug 2018
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Cover Translation
copyright	Joa Hug 2016
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Unfinished thinking
copyright	Joa Hug 2008
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Earth Stage, Body Weather Farm, 1991.
copyright	Contemporary Arts Media / Artfilms
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Chapter 3 background image
copyright	Hug 2019
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Nivel cover
copyright	Joa Hug 2016
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture, picture

name	05172019 Unfinished Thinking low voulume
copyright	Hug 2019
license	All rights reserved
usages	audio

name	Script Lecture-Performance
copyright	Hug 2013
license	All rights reserved
usages	pdf

name	Proposal
copyright	Hug 2013
license	All rights reserved
usages	pdf

name	Hollo Institute Research Symposium 2013 CFP
copyright	Hollo Institute
license	All rights reserved
usages	pdf

name	Info Website Ehkä
copyright	Ehkä
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	IPPT Helsinki
copyright	IPPT
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture, picture, picture

name	Screen Shot 2019-07-14 at 22.09.14
copyright	SAAR
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	SAAR_program_2014
copyright	SAAR
license	All rights reserved
usages	pdf

name	Presentation1_SAAR
copyright	Hug 2014
license	All rights reserved
usages	pdf

name	Report JH
copyright	Hug 2014
license	All rights reserved
usages	pdf

name	Screen Shot 2019-07-14 at 22.33.51
copyright	Gnothi Seauton
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Journal Report_JHug_final
copyright	Hug 2014
license	All rights reserved
usages	pdf

name	Jak-vime-co-vime
copyright	Hug 2014
license	All rights reserved
usages	pdf

name	Screen Shot 2019-07-15 at 21.16.11
copyright	NOFOD
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	CfPa
copyright	NOFOD
license	All rights reserved
usages	pdf

name	Script NOFOD 27052015
copyright	Hug 2015
license	All rights reserved
usages	pdf

name	Proposal JHug
copyright	Hug 2015
license	All rights reserved
usages	pdf

name	NOFOD-Proceedings
copyright	NOFOD
license	All rights reserved
usages	pdf

name	IMG_3193
copyright	Elizabeth Svarstad
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	IMG_3197
copyright	Elizabeth Svarstad
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Screen Shot 2019-07-15 at 22.32.02
copyright	CARPA
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Call Carpa
copyright	CARPA
license	All rights reserved
usages	pdf

name	CARPA4 Presenters Abstracts
copyright	CARPA
license	All rights reserved
usages	pdf

name	Screen Shot 2019-07-17 at 20.50.05
copyright	GTF
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	GTF RC1
copyright	Astarti Athanasiadou
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	GTF RC 2
copyright	Astarti Athanasiadou
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	GTF_PaR_Programm
copyright	GTF
license	All rights reserved
usages	pdf

name	Script Presentation GTF 29102015
copyright	Hug 2015
license	All rights reserved
usages	pdf

name	Archive 1
copyright	Hug 2015
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	MPI 1
copyright	Hug 2015
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	MPI 2
copyright	Hug 2015
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	IPPT 2016_Tradition_Call for Proposals
copyright	IPPT2016
license	All rights reserved
usages	pdf

name	IPPT Wroclaw 2016 - program
copyright	IPPT2016
license	All rights reserved
usages	pdf

name	Grenoble
copyright	Grenoble
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Grenoble4
copyright	Hug 2016
license	All rights reserved
usages	pdf

name	SCSV2016 - Programme
copyright	Grenoble
license	All rights reserved
usages	pdf

name	Appel Colloque Sciences Cognitives et Spectacle Vivant - V 3 sept 2015
copyright	Grenoble
license	All rights reserved
usages	pdf

name	Conference AR CFP
copyright	APA Prague
license	All rights reserved
usages	pdf

name	PresentationPrague6
copyright	Hug 2016
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Playful communication - CFP
copyright	Playful Communication
license	All rights reserved
usages	pdf

name	Proposal_JHug
copyright	Hug 2016
license	All rights reserved
usages	pdf

name	Zimmer4
copyright	Hug 2017
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Solo basteling
copyright	Kramer & Hug
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Abstracts
copyright	SAR 2017
license	All rights reserved
usages	pdf

name	Screen Shot 2019-07-20 at 21.41.10
copyright	ADiE
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	ADiE STOCKHOLM PRACTICE WEEK March 19-24, 2018
copyright	ADiE
license	All rights reserved
usages	pdf

name	What and How
copyright	Hug 2017
license	All rights reserved
usages	video

name	Hug_2016_Modes_of Knowing
copyright	Hug, Joa. 2016b. “Modes of Knowing in Body Weather Performance Training.” In Zwischenleiblichkeit und bewegtes Verstehen: Intercorporeity, Movement and Tacit Knowledge, ed. Undine Enderlein, 367–380. Bielefeld: Transcript. Reproduced by permission of transcript Verlag
license	All rights reserved
usages	pdf

name	Eberlein 2016 Contents
copyright	Hug, Joa. 2016b. “Modes of Knowing in Body Weather Performance Training.” In Zwischenleiblichkeit und bewegtes Verstehen: Intercorporeity, Movement and Tacit Knowledge, ed. Undine Enderlein, 367–380. Bielefeld: Transcript.
license	All rights reserved
usages	pdf

name	Screen Shot 2019-07-21 at 21.24.53
copyright	Theatre, Dance and Performance Training
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Writing with practice Body Weather performance training becomes a medium of artistic research
copyright	Reproduced by permission of Taylor & Francis/Routledge
license	All rights reserved
usages	pdf

name	Cover
copyright	Daniela Jobertová & Alice Koubová (eds.). 2017. "Artistic Research: Is There Some Method?" Prague: Academy for Performing Arts.
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Hug_No_solutions_2017
copyright	Hug 2017
license	All rights reserved
usages	pdf

name	Senate House 2
copyright	Hug 2016
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	RC FAP
copyright	Hug 2016
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	HugJ_Linking_paper
copyright	Hug 2016
license	All rights reserved
usages	pdf

name	Screen Shot 2019-07-22 at 12.32.46
copyright	Hug 2016
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Screen Shot 2019-07-22 at 13.00.42
copyright	Hug 2017
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	One-on-One 2 new
copyright	Hug 2016
license	All rights reserved
usages	video

name	OneonOne Riikka
copyright	Hug 2016
license	All rights reserved
usages	image

name	Exposition V2 low
copyright	Theatre Academy Helsinki & Hug (2016)
license	All rights reserved
usages	video

name	Exposition V2 preview
copyright	Hug 2016
license	All rights reserved
usages	image

name	Screen Shot 2019-08-22 at 16.36.12
copyright	Hug 2016
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	AREAL Berlin
copyright	Hug 2012
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Screen Shot 2020-05-20 at 08.09.35
copyright	Joa Hug
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	References_final
copyright	Joa Hug
license	All rights reserved
usages	pdf

name	Theatre Academy
copyright	Theatre Academy
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Acknowledgements_final
copyright	Joa Hug
license	All rights reserved
usages	pdf

name	PDFVersion_final
copyright	Joa Hug
license	All rights reserved
usages	pdf

name	Manips 1&2
copyright	Joa Hug 2008
license	All rights reserved
usages	video, video

name	bwfarm 1991 (dragged)
copyright	serge tampalini 1991
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Text1
copyright	Hug 2012
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Text 3
copyright	Hug 2012
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Text 2
copyright	Hug 2012
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Text 1
copyright	Hug 2012
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Text 7
copyright	Hug
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Text 6
copyright	Hug 2012
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

name	Text 5
copyright	Hug 2012
license	All rights reserved
usages	picture

comments: 1 (last entry by Elisabeth Laasonen Belgrano - 20/04/2018 at 13:40)

Research Catalogue

an international database for artistic research

Propositions for Unfinished Thinking: The Research Score as a Medium of Artistic Research (2020)

Copyrights